Title: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on May 29, 2008, 03:39:13 am What is the ideal air fuel ratio range for a street engine? I'll be tuning my car with the LM-1 soon, and it's been so long since I've used one of those that I've forgotten. Thanks!
Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: GreenTom on May 29, 2008, 18:46:42 pm in theory is 14,7:1.
Go to innovate motorsport forum You'll get all answers. Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: louisb on May 29, 2008, 18:57:16 pm Not for an aircooled. If you run it too lean it will run hot. Check aircooled.net's tuning recommendations for some starters.
--louis Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: GreenTom on May 29, 2008, 20:16:53 pm Not for an aircooled. If you run it too lean it will run hot. Check aircooled.net's tuning recommendations for some starters. oh yes that's true. too lean too hot--louis Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Felix/DFL on May 29, 2008, 20:44:17 pm Hi,
you want to get in the regions from 11,7-12,5 A/F Ratio. That`s Lambda 0,8-0,85, there the ingnition speed is maximum, so the detonation is very fast and that`s good for the power output... This region is on the rich side so there should be no problems with overheating. A/F 14,7:1 is Lambda 1 where the 3 three-way catalytic converter has his best converting point, as said way to lean for an hot aircooled engine. Greetz ! Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Jim Ratto on May 29, 2008, 21:16:30 pm I set mine @
idle 11.6-12.2 cruise on idle/progression 12.8-13.2 cruise on main (freeway) 12.0-12.7 full open throttle 11.5-11.8 Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Bruce on May 30, 2008, 04:04:48 am Not for an aircooled. If you run it too lean it will run hot. Ever tested that theory? Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: louisb on May 30, 2008, 05:21:10 am Have I ever run a VW lean? Yeah and it ran hot. Was it exactly 14.1, I have no idea since I don't have an LM1. I would just prefer to have a little cushion.
--louis Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Bruce on May 31, 2008, 01:04:50 am My engine runs around 18:1 on the freeway. No cooling issues.
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 28, 2008, 16:40:04 pm I finally got around to tuning my Zenith 32NDIX with the LM-1 yesterday :) Fruitcake and I started out with a baseline drive, and the jetting was very close as I expected- it drove very well so I knew it couldn't be too far off. But the idle and main circut could have still used a little leaning out- impossible to tell by just looking at the spark plugs. Instead of going straight to the jet box, I wanted to try out some larger Porsche 28mm venturies (up from 24mm), to see what the effect on A/F ratio was, and to see if there was a top end performance gain. Right off the bat, I noticed the idle circut was VERY lean, 19-20:1, and the engine was very unhappy- lots of bucking and kicking until I stepped on it and got on to the mains. But once it was floored, I was pleasantly surpirsed! It pulls MUCH stronger now up high!! :) Anyway, my Zenith came with 50 idle fuels, and 140 idle airs. When I first installed the carb I swapped the 50's for 40's, thinking the stock engine wouldnt need that much fuel, and I guess I was right. But now with the 28mm vents, the idle circut was far too lean. So I went back to the 50 idle fuels, and the problem got quite a bit better. Now the A/F ratio is in the 16-17:1 range (and the engine still isn't happy), and of course still too lean.
SO.... My question for now is this: Do I drill out the idle fuels to 55 and give that a try, OR try a smaller idle air jet? Both would richen up the mixture, but how do I know which path to take? Surprisingly, the main circut is still a little on the rich side (135 fuel, 220 air.... I think), and I would like to try leaning that out some. So once again, do I increase the air jet, or decrease the fuel jet to lean out the mixture?? THANKS!!! ;D Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 28, 2008, 19:23:19 pm I robbed a pair of 60 idles out of another parts carb that I had lying around, but I havent had a chance to screw them in yet, I'll have to wait until after work.
Another question along the same lines... increasing the fuel jet size in order to richen the mixture woulld have a negative effect on mileage (right??)... Would decreasing the air jet not effect the mileage, yet also give me the richer mixture that I'm after?? Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: j-dub on July 29, 2008, 01:51:49 am Zach,
Check out this thread on the Samba and notice what John@aircooled.net says: http://www.thesamba.com/vw/forum/viewtopic.php?t=293837&start=0&postdays=0&postorder=asc He has a different approach on AFR, what runs hot and total timing. I just installed Travis's LM-1 on my oval this weekend and am just starting down the tuning road myself. I have yet to find much helpfull information on Innovatives website, maybe I am not looking in the right place. Let us know what you find out works best for you engine. Jeremy Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 29, 2008, 02:47:23 am Hey Jeremy good to see you here! I'll give that link a try...
I just got back from the trial run with the 60 idle fuel jets and it really didn't make much of a difference at all >:( So I think the 50 idles are the ticket, but what I really need is some smaller idle airs. I know some Porsche Zenith 32's came with 120's, so I'd really like to find a pair of those, but I'll try anything smaller at this point. Anyone??? Once I get the idle where I want it, I'm going to start leaning out the mains a little... Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 29, 2008, 18:24:02 pm I set mine @ idle 11.6-12.2 cruise on idle/progression 12.8-13.2 cruise on main (freeway) 12.0-12.7 full open throttle 11.5-11.8 Jim, why do you run the idle so rich?? There is no load at idle, so it seems to me that you could run it as lean as possible ??? Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Jim Ratto on July 29, 2008, 18:29:58 pm because that is where it runs well. The "numbers" don't make my car run correctly.
I tired "leaning" it out, but it runs very poorly. So I can drive around watching the meter telling me "things are great" and the car runs poorly, Or i can jet it so it rips the seat off the rails and forget the "numbers" BTW I run a 60 idle jet in 120 holder and 7/8 turns out on mix screws Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Airspeed on July 29, 2008, 20:40:46 pm My engine runs around 18:1 on the freeway. No cooling issues. My hero! I will definately give that a try with the EFI (was afraid to do that before..) ::) I do however up the advance to 43 degrees at low trottle opening and cruise rpms ;D Must give some awesome mph with such a high AFR (?) Tnx for the encouragement! Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: JS on July 29, 2008, 21:08:05 pm Jim, why do you run the idle so rich?? There is no load at idle, so it seems to me that you could run it as lean as possible ??? [/quote] My IDAīs make the car undrivable if I put in idle jets under 60. The "blind-spot" between idle and main jet becomes bigger and bigger the more I lean it out. Running 65īs now, and itīs too rich of course, but very pleasant to drive. And when you rev it, it flies! ;D Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 30, 2008, 02:17:46 am Thanks for the explanation. Silly me, I didn't take into account the fact that IDA's are a completely different beast ;)
I've got some 120 idle airs on the way, if that doesn't do it, I don't know where to go next :-\ Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: j-dub on August 01, 2008, 06:15:07 am Hey Zach, Any update?
I have went down two sizes on my idle jets and am still idling in the range of 11.8 to 12.2, when i am at a light acceleration it is at 13.8 to 14.3. It dips into the 11s during full throttle pulls. I guess I am going to continue to go smaller idle jets until it protests. After that I will address the main jet and accelerator pump. Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 01, 2008, 20:55:59 pm I've got 2 120 idle air jets coming from a Zenith specialist in Sedona, hopefull they'll be here today. Hopefully that will do the trick. Once I get that dialed in I'll try leaning out the mains, but I think they may already be good to go. I've also got some 40 accelerator pump jets that I'll try in place of the 55's.
Once it cools down I'll make the drive down to Phoenix to flog it on the strip one more time- maybe 18's are in my future :D Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 04, 2008, 19:08:56 pm I screwed the smaller 120 idle airs in Friday after work. Still has a mid-range lean spot under light load/acceleration (gets up to about 16:1 at times) and the engine feels a little rough :( It's a real pain in the ass driving around town because that is the range I'm always in. I havent had a chance to mess with the idle mixture screws yet, hopefully fattening them up some will help the problem?? Or are the 28mm venturi's simply too large for my stock(ish)engine??? I'd really appreciate some advise here guys!!! :)
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: dirk zeyen on August 04, 2008, 22:14:24 pm the venturi's are not your problem. i run 45 dell's with 36 venturi's on a 2007cc engine with 35,5 inlet valves and it works!!!
i'm not happy with a lean runing engine. dirk zeyen Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 04, 2008, 23:01:26 pm the venturi's are not your problem. i run 45 dell's with 36 venturi's on a 2007cc engine with 35,5 inlet valves and it works!!! i'm not happy with a lean runing engine. dirk zeyen So what is the problem?? Operator error?? :D I ran dual 44idf's with 36mm venturies on a (well built) 1600, and it worked well... but I have heard tales of VW engines with single 2bbl carburetors like mine that work better with smaller venturies. Something to do with the long intake runners needing a small venturi to keep airspeed up. Does anyone have a similar experience? I would prefer to keep the larger venturi's in the engine, because after 3,000rpm it really woke it up! What else can I do?? BTW, I am using a Bosch 010 w/ Pertronix, 35 degrees total advance, if it matters... Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Mike Lawless on August 05, 2008, 17:29:56 pm If you have the smaller vents, it's only a little work to try it Zach. Give it a shot!
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 05, 2008, 22:43:59 pm I love the 28mm vents.... above 3,000 rpm! :-\ The 24's ran out of steam very early, passing power with the 28's was also increased noticably.
I'll check the float level.. good idea! :) Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: dirk zeyen on August 07, 2008, 22:38:14 pm float level checked? any news? my opinion is that a engine with bigger vents needs a mixture more on the rich side
dirk zeyen Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 08, 2008, 18:23:50 pm Float level is good :-\
I'm about to throw in the towel on these larger venturis >:( Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 15, 2008, 18:24:40 pm I'm getting somewhere!!! ;D
I talked to Steve Hollingsworth last week about my problem. He suggested raising the floats and putting in a larger main jet (from a 135 to a 140), to get the main circut to come on sooner, going larger on the air correction jets to lean out the full throttle A/F ratio (from a 180 to a 200), and going back to the 50 idle fuels since the 60's didnt make a difference.... So I did. I know you arent supposed to make 4 changes at once, but I was getting impatient!! :D I fired up the motor, and it was running extremely rich. So rich in fact, that it completely flooded out the motor in less than 30 seconds of idling, and it wouldn't restart >:( Frustrated, I waited until the next morning and started it again. It does the same thing. I swapped out the raised float for a standard one, and the motor runs great! Except that it was running really fat under full throttle, and a bit rich everywhere else... but at least it was smooth!! So I pulled the 120 idle airs and went back to the 140s, and also took the air correction jets from 200, to 220, and now at 230- they bearly made a difference, still rich under full throttle >:( long story short, I gauged the main jets and found out that the main jets that were first in the carb, stamped 135, were actually 125s! So last night I leaned it back down to a true 135, and it still runs great, about .5 leaner under full throttle. So tonight I'm going to screw in a pair of 130's and see what happens. Right now my full throttle A/F ratio is hovering around the high 10's... Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: dirk zeyen on August 15, 2008, 22:46:15 pm hello zach,
like i said: small valves with "big" vents need a rich mixture!!! the air correction jets comes in at a rpm range a stock engine comes not in so easy so your changes makes no big difference! good to hear your engine runs!!! dirk zeyen Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: John Rayburn on August 16, 2008, 23:17:21 pm If you ignore all of it and just spend the time jetting and test driving, you'll get it done alot faster and the engine will run way better than listening to some computer.
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 18, 2008, 04:56:55 am I don't know about that. I think this tool has taught me quite a bit in a short time. I still have a long way to go, but I'm getting there :)
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Allen Wiess on August 18, 2008, 19:39:31 pm If you ignore all of it and just spend the time jetting and test driving, you'll get it done alot faster and the engine will run way better than listening to some computer. Or just get rid of the dinosaur pissers and go EFI :o ;D :D ......... What the hell are jets :-X Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Jim Ratto on August 18, 2008, 19:58:07 pm Man, if these Zeniths are this much of a bitch, Sheep, aren't you glad we AREN'T using one?!
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: dirk zeyen on August 18, 2008, 20:15:03 pm EFI is oldschool in 2040 :o :o so what the hell is EFI ;D :o ;D
dirk zeyen Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 18, 2008, 23:01:04 pm Nawww, I don't think they are bad at all. My only gripe about the carb is that you have to take it off the manifold in order to access the fuel jets (right next to the fanshroud). The carb top has to come off the get to the airs as well, so jetting is a little more time consuming than average. The motor is running very sweet now though, I'm happy :)
I still have yet to try out the 130's because I'm a little doubtful that they will work. When I get a little extra time on my hands I'll give it a shot and let ya'll know. ;) Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on October 02, 2008, 18:19:52 pm I got the 130's in, and just as I expected it was a little too lean under light acceleration- like mid 15's to mid 16's. It had a bit of a stumble right at that point, as well. But the full throttle A/F ratio is much better- it went from the high 10's to the high 11's. So I took out the 140 idle airs and swapped the 120's back in to try and richen up the midrange, and WHA-LAA! It's right back to where it was in the middle, and leaner under full throttle :) Next I'm going to try a smaller accelerator pump jet... I'll let ya'll know what happens.
I don't care what anyone says, the LM-1 kicks arse ;D Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: dirk zeyen on October 02, 2008, 20:10:30 pm problems with zenith: ask doctor zach!!! ;D ;D ;D
dirk zeyen Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Diederick/DVK on October 03, 2008, 00:26:48 am sounds like it's quite a task zach!
how do you connect an LM-1 anyhow? good luck on it ;) Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on October 03, 2008, 00:57:08 am sounds like it's quite a task zach! how do you connect an LM-1 anyhow? good luck on it ;) Very simple to hook up... I made a spacer at the collector flange with an O2 bung welded in, and I installed a few "hidden" power outlets under the rear seat. I'll post some pics later. After a little more driving it still seems a tad bit lean on the mid range- tolerable for this altitude (over 5,000ft), but maybe not so much for lower elevation. I'm going to keep the LM-1 hooked up for the trip to Vegas (2500ft I believe) this weekend to see what happens... Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: 67worshipper on October 03, 2008, 08:33:14 am was it much money then zach? may invest in one myself. id like to tune the idas for myself really ;)
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Jim Ratto on October 03, 2008, 18:40:52 pm was it much money then zach? may invest in one myself. id like to tune the idas for myself really ;) I bought the NGK AF sensor. A friend of mine that dyno tunes Porsches turned me onto it. NGK AFX sensor. Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on November 27, 2008, 00:21:41 am A while ago I pulled out the 28mm venturi's, and swapped them for a pair of 25's that were in my parts carb. I could never get the 28's to work perfectly... there was always a compromise somewhere. So I did that, put the idle fuels back down to 40's with 140 airs, and installed 125 mains. I didn't loose much on the top end power-wise, and it is much more driveable now. I also got 28mpg a few weeks ago on a trip down to Phoenix (mixed Interstate, freeway, and city driving). So I was pretty happy with that... but I tried another change- 185 airs instead of the 230's. Didn't change a thing, so I'm leaving it as is. Here is how I had it set up in my car- spacer adapter at the collector, wires through the quarter window, powered under the rear seat, monitor sits in the console so I could glance at it easily.
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on November 28, 2008, 21:20:11 pm So in hindsight, I should have just swapped the 24 vents for the 25's and left everything else alone! ::) It was an educational experience though ;)
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: marcd on December 02, 2008, 08:34:32 am was it much money then zach? may invest in one myself. id like to tune the idas for myself really ;) Innovate Motorsports lists their "Basic" kit starting at $349.95 http://www.innovatemotorsports.com/products/lm1.php (http://www.innovatemotorsports.com/products/lm1.php) The Basic Kit ($349) includes the LM-1 meter, a Bosch wide-band oxygen sensor, 10 ft sensor cable, cigarette-lighter power adapter, serial cable for PC connection, 9V battery, exhaust bung and plug, CD and quick-start guide. There is a neat DIY wide-band out there which is quite a bit cheaper and works just as well as the LM-1. http://www.14point7.com/JAW/JAW.htm (http://www.14point7.com/JAW/JAW.htm) JAW is the lowest priced wideband oxygen sensor reader ever. Product Features: $45 DIY Kit: Without Display $70 DIY Kit: With Display $80 Assembled: Without Display $115 Assembled: With Display Uses the inexpensive Bosch LSU Wideband Sensor. Accuracy to 0.01 Lambda. 2 programmable outputs Free Air Calibration Real-time datalogging User selectable refresh rate of 8-255 [hz] for digital display Reads from 0.69 [Lambda] to 2.33 [Lambda] Reads from 10.18 [AFR] - 34.28 [AFR] This will likely find it's way on my car after I am finished with the new exhaust. 42's are nice but I am getting horrible mileage. Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: John Maher on December 02, 2008, 10:45:45 am I don't consider the LM-1 a serious tuning tool
Lack of accuracy and its inability to cope with moderately high EGTs make it worthless for ACCURATE mapping/jetting Maybe this has been addressed with the introduction of the LM-2 ::) Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: LGK on December 02, 2008, 14:03:04 pm I don't consider the LM-1 a serious tuning tool Lack of accuracy and its inability to cope with moderately high EGTs make it worthless for ACCURATE mapping/jetting Maybe this has been addressed with the introduction of the LM-2 ::) I have to agree with John on this one. I like the wideband-commander from dynojet a lot or the motec system. Steve Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 07, 2009, 01:22:35 am I need a little carb basics 101!
What about the needle and seat? So please educate me; if it is too small then the bowl could run dry, but if it is too large then the float would just stop flow, correct?? Does the size effect driveability?? If so, in what way? I can get different sizes from this guy, and if I can pick up a little free mileage or power in some way I wouldn't be objective to that. Or should I just shut up and keep what I've got in there?? Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: Fiatdude on July 07, 2009, 07:35:47 am I set mine @ idle 11.6-12.2 cruise on idle/progression 12.8-13.2 cruise on main (freeway) 12.0-12.7 full open throttle 11.5-11.8 perfect -- unless your turbo then 11.5 everywhere Title: Re: A/F ratio Post by: K-Roc on July 07, 2009, 18:20:09 pm I set mine @ idle 11.6-12.2 cruise on idle/progression 12.8-13.2 cruise on main (freeway) 12.0-12.7 full open throttle 11.5-11.8 perfect -- unless your turbo then 11.5 everywhere Hi,I finally have my new map all tweaked in ( Megasquirt ) 2332 With 044 heads 9.8:1 comp You set up your Air fuel ratio target 12X12 grid with map/RPM then load in some basic VE numbers and go for a drive, the Megasquirt slowly zero's in on your desired A/F numbers, the hard part is finding the right road to get to 7200 ROM in 4th gear ;) Idle is around 13.8 ( can't get it any leaner with an FK47) Light cruise and low load Highway 14.7-15:1 ( no cooling problems what so ever) Full load Max torque is at 12.8:1 11.5-11.8 under full throttle with a N/A engine is pig rich. try around 12.8 as see how much crisper it runs. The best test here is a Dyno or Trap speeds in the 1/4 Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Bruce on July 08, 2009, 06:20:31 am What about the needle and seat? Too small for the inlet valve and you run the risk of emptying the bowl. Engine goes lean.So please educate me; if it is too small then the bowl could run dry, but if it is too large then the float would just stop flow, correct?? Too large and the fuel level will exceed the set point when the valve opens, causing the engine to momentarily go rich. Then lean. Then rich....... There are simple guidelines in the Weber carb manuals. Engine hp determines the inlet valve size needed. How much hp do you have? What size is the stock inlet valve in your carbs? Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 08, 2009, 06:43:24 am Thanks, Bruce. You saw my motor... I'm lucky if I'm pushing 60hp! :D
Single Zenith applications came with a 1.75, duals were 1.25's. I guess since I'm not experiencing any rich/lean problems, I should just stick with the 1.75 Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Bruce on July 09, 2009, 03:23:15 am 1.75 is on the big side. 1.5 would be better. But if you're having no trouble, don't mess with it.
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on July 09, 2009, 07:12:25 am I'll try the 1.50's... I've got nothing to lose ;)
Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Fiatdude on July 10, 2009, 16:35:32 pm was it much money then zach? may invest in one myself. id like to tune the idas for myself really ;) I've got a LM-2 -- Used it to tune the Fiat for about a week and it has been setting of the shelf since so it is basically brand new -- make me an offer Title: Re: A/F ratio- Tuning with the LM-1 Post by: Zach Gomulka on August 25, 2009, 18:29:05 pm Screwed a 1.50 in there and all seems well. The Zenith used to have a bit of an issue with sweating fuel, this seems to have solved it :)
|