The Cal-look Lounge

Cal-look/High Performance => Cal-look => Topic started by: peach_ on May 27, 2009, 20:04:59 pm



Title: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: peach_ on May 27, 2009, 20:04:59 pm
Does Anyone Run a After-Market "Windich Tray" In the High Hp Vw engine?
Or are they not really worth it?
Iv heard that a "Windich Tray" is built into a type-1 case anyway, but was just wondering if anyone could shed anymore light on the subject?

cheers


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: Donny B. on May 27, 2009, 20:11:22 pm
I actually have one that I got in a trade a long time ago.  I never used it.  Heard they can cause oil starvation and don't work that well.  I used to use windage pushrod tubes from CB.  They I believe worked pretty well.  Just run a big sump, that works.


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: stealth67vw on May 27, 2009, 20:13:46 pm
I tried to use one when I was 16 and it did not clear the cam.


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: Fiatdude on May 28, 2009, 05:10:56 am
I've got one in my 2919 -- keeps the oil from the crank and helps it from "foaming"

V8's say it worth about 1% HP gain by keeping the crank from having to slice through the oil


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: marc1951 on May 28, 2009, 05:21:09 am
Toss it!
I tried one years ago and the only thing it did was break loose and rattle a lot.

I've built scores of high performance VW engines and what has always worked for me is to
use a sump and run your oil level a bit low on the dipstick to keep the crank out of the oil and churning through it.

Marc Buehler
DRA


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: Rennsurfer on May 28, 2009, 07:15:43 am
Wow, people still make windage trays?
(https://wolfgangint.com/_images/parts/1115107.jpg)
Haven't heard that word in 25 years. Thought they left with the early '80s. Never used one and don't really plan to. But... to each their own.


Title: Re: Does Anyone Run One Of these In there Hot Vw Engine and is It worth it?
Post by: Bruce on May 28, 2009, 15:44:46 pm
I've got one in my 2919 -- keeps the oil from the crank and helps it from "foaming"
How do you know that?