The Cal-look Lounge

Cal-look/High Performance => Cal-look => Topic started by: Bewitched666 on August 27, 2009, 07:11:53 am



Title: Broken axels
Post by: Bewitched666 on August 27, 2009, 07:11:53 am
Guys,

last weekend i went to see some dragracing at our international raceway in drachten holland.
I met Udo Becker and had a chat with him and shared some racing talk. He showed me a broken axel that occured on the friday of eliminations.

Udo was wondering if the racing axels need to be replaced after a period of abuse. Now i have my share of broken axels too and started wondering now if it was due to the years gone by of using the axels or that it was due to the fresh traction compound or other issues.

I will check this with Rancho and Dave Folts who are some of the best gearbox guru's and reply but does anyone have an idea if axels need to be replaced after some years? ???


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: jamiep_jamiep on August 27, 2009, 09:16:14 am
As I understand it, the material used to make race axles is selected to allow a certain amount of 'twist' to the axle, which prevents breakage over the more brittle stock component.

Maybe it work hardens and the more stress cycles its put through the less it 'gives'?


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Bewitched666 on August 27, 2009, 11:37:20 am
I cant really tell kaferboy.

We'll see what some axelpro's have as an answer 8)


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: richie on August 27, 2009, 12:15:45 pm
They are all junk right now,I was at Rancho yesterday talking to Mike herbert about the latest Sway a way axles,it seems they are not even correctly machined with some having as much as .100thou out of round new :o  Some of the quicker turbo cars are only getting 6/8 passes from them before changing them or they break :o,this is one of the reasons Eric madsons ghia was changed to IRS last year

cheers richie,uk


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: jamiep_jamiep on August 27, 2009, 12:27:27 pm
Is it the material or the finishing thats letting them down Richie?


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: BeetleBug on August 27, 2009, 12:53:50 pm
Is it the material or the finishing thats letting them down Richie?

Both.

Conclusion; do not risk your safety and buy some quality axles instead.


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Udo on August 27, 2009, 18:04:34 pm
The one i broke was a very old one from a customers car that had a big type4 engine. For me it is ok so far and i change them to new ones over the winter . But what richie says sounds not good ... , but what axels can be used ?

Udo


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: BeetleBug on August 27, 2009, 18:56:45 pm
what axels can be used ?
Udo

Karpiola, hand made somewhere deep deep inside the Finnish forest by a 149 year old guy and his son. Contact Jussi for more info.


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Martin on August 27, 2009, 23:09:04 pm
I tried to get them to make me some..... might have been asking too much of them

Ive worked out my own solution ;)


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: kraftwerk on August 28, 2009, 10:43:54 am
so, if i go irs, what are my options there?? do i need to run type2/25 cv joints, are there bigger/stronger axles out there for this setup? can i get some made to my own wifth, as im thinking of narrowing the rear somewhat! any and all comments would be appreciated!! ps,.. sorry, didnt mean to hi-jack the thread!  :-[


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: richie on August 28, 2009, 15:00:39 pm
Ive worked out my own solution ;)


you did? what I heard was something completely different and you upset some people doing it?


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: richie on August 28, 2009, 15:05:36 pm
so, if i go irs, what are my options there?? do i need to run type2/25 cv joints, are there bigger/stronger axles out there for this setup? can i get some made to my own wifth, as im thinking of narrowing the rear somewhat! any and all comments would be appreciated!! ps,.. sorry, didnt mean to hi-jack the thread!  :-[

There are several cv and axle solutions for irs,the bus/t2/early 944 is good enough for most but the current sway a way axles available are suspect,you can have irs axles made and the 300m material is very strong,particularly when rifle drilled,then there is what is known as the 930[the porsche model the came on originally] option,which when combined with the 3oom rifle drilled axles is vertually unbreakable,the axles are made any length you want

cheeers richie,uk


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Martin on August 28, 2009, 16:50:14 pm
Ive worked out my own solution ;)


you did? what I heard was something completely different and you upset some people doing it?

its my interpretation on a Rancho idea, but mines in and working, its very diferent to theres.

As for upsetting people, dont know who you mean as every one i was speaking to before are still speaking to me now.


its amazing what Chinese whispers can do, LMAO


Ah well, must get back to it, ive got a new cam to slip into the cash converter


Martin

PS I have a load of 300m if anyone wants axles making ;)


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: gator_push on August 31, 2009, 12:13:00 pm
They are all junk right now,I was at Rancho yesterday talking to Mike herbert about the latest Sway a way axles,it seems they are not even correctly machined with some having as much as .100thou out of round new :o  Some of the quicker turbo cars are only getting 6/8 passes from them before changing them or they break :o,this is one of the reasons Eric madsons ghia was changed to IRS last year

cheers richie,uk

Richie,

are there any hints when the first bad batches entered the market?

Peter


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Bewitched666 on September 01, 2009, 07:07:51 am
Btw how much abuse can a stock axel take? ???


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Lids on September 01, 2009, 08:26:43 am
i swore at mine loads, no problems. :P ;D


Title: Re: Broken axels
Post by: Jon on September 01, 2009, 10:05:58 am
i swore at mine loads, no problems. :P ;D
;D