The Cal-look Lounge

Cal-look/High Performance => Technical stuff => Topic started by: RobtheManx on December 14, 2016, 23:32:10 pm



Title: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 14, 2016, 23:32:10 pm
Please help me !

Getting close to driving my 67 for the first time , but brakes are holding me up , can't get rid of the spongy pedal .

Everything is new , master cylinder has a reservoir mounted directly on top , It has a line lock fitted on the floor of the frame head , next to the master .
I have adjusted the pushrod correctly , all brakes are adjusted fully ( planning to back them off once the pedal is hard ) .

I've put at least 4 litres of fluid through it , no air coming out anywhere , I've pressure bled it , bled by pumping the pedal myself and then going to each bleed nipple , and done bleeding with a friend pumping the pedal .

As I was getting nowhere , I took the master off , blanked the ports and bench bled it like I do with masters on american cars . Re-fit the master with plugs still in place , and the pedal is rock hard ( so this mean the master is good ? and has no air in it right ? )

Connect up the front pipe and bleed , pedal feels a bit worse . Connect up the rears , bleed , pedal is worse still . In fact , I can nearly push it to the bulkhead !

Should I try a new master ?

Any advise greatly appreciated , better still come to my house and sort it for me cause I'm sick of it ! will pay with pizza and beer

Thanks , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 15, 2016, 08:23:08 am
Discs on front? The only time I have had a drama bleeding brakes was when we had the front calipers on upside down and the bleed nipple was at the bottom
Lee


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 09:49:46 am
No , drums all round . Sorry , should have said.


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 15, 2016, 10:01:52 am
I kind of guessed drums when you said you had adjusted them right up!
Sorry, nothing else to suggest
Lee


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Neil Davies on December 15, 2016, 10:22:07 am
How old are the new flexi pipes? I've had one collapse internally before.


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Andy on December 15, 2016, 10:58:07 am
If you think you have got all the air out, could it be a mechanical problem.
 It could be the handbrake spreader bar is holding the shoes away from the cylinder giving the excess travel at the pedal.


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: alex d on December 15, 2016, 13:08:29 pm
on dual circuit cars I like to bleed the rears first, seems to work better for me


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 15, 2016, 15:18:07 pm
I thought you always started with the wheel furthest away from master cylinder?
Lee


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: alex d on December 15, 2016, 15:30:01 pm
sorry, I meant the opposite, I do the fronts first, actually that's how the workshop manual tells you to do it  :D

on single circuit cars I do start on the wheel farthest away


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 18:18:37 pm
If you think you have got all the air out, could it be a mechanical problem.
 It could be the handbrake spreader bar is holding the shoes away from the cylinder giving the excess travel at the pedal.


Not thought about that , I'll  try backing the handbrake off . cheers


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 18:20:22 pm
The flexi hoses are about 6 month old , I bought them when I put the chassis together . They've never been clamped or anything .

I have tried bleeding the fronts first and the rears first !


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: spoolin70 on December 15, 2016, 19:32:41 pm
Are you bleeding with the car on level ground ?

I was having trouble with a soft pedal before and a mate swore jacking up the end your bleeding worked best.

Large car jack, rear of the car jacked up so the valance was chest hight, rears bled. Opposite with the front and hay presto, solid pedal  ;D

Worth a try
Darren


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 22:42:50 pm
If you think you have got all the air out, could it be a mechanical problem.
 It could be the handbrake spreader bar is holding the shoes away from the cylinder giving the excess travel at the pedal.


Not thought about that , I'll  try backing the handbrake off . cheers

Tried that now , no difference .


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 22:45:04 pm
Another thing I've noticed , although the shoes and drums are all new , I have had to adjust the brakes a lot before they bite . the adjusters are nearly halfway out . surely that can't be right ?


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 15, 2016, 22:48:14 pm
Are you bleeding with the car on level ground ?

I was having trouble with a soft pedal before and a mate swore jacking up the end your bleeding worked best.

Large car jack, rear of the car jacked up so the valance was chest hight, rears bled. Opposite with the front and hay presto, solid pedal  ;D

Worth a try
Darren
[/quote

Ok , this sounds like the next idea to try .

Did you do it with someone pumping the pedal , or pressure bleed Darren ?


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Taylor on December 16, 2016, 03:40:57 am
What procedure are you using currently?   I've had best luck putting a hose on the bleeder and opening it. Putting the hose in a jar with some fluid and just pumping away for a while.   Do all four wheels like that.   U can do it by yourself.   Then do the pump and hold method for the final pass or two.


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Elnef on December 16, 2016, 06:06:17 am
A friend of mine did have some problem with new brake hose they where to soft 


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: spoolin70 on December 16, 2016, 07:50:13 am
Hi Rob

Only used the pedal but obviously with the car up at such an angle, you don't really want to be fidgeting around  ;)

Good luck
Darren


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: alex d on December 16, 2016, 08:08:33 am
What year car is this? Are you 100% sure that you have the correct adjusters with the correct shoes and the right way up?

Shoes match the drums too?


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 16, 2016, 10:17:22 am
What year car is this? Are you 100% sure that you have the correct adjusters with the correct shoes and the right way up?

Shoes match the drums too?

Its a US spec 67 , but I've gone over to shirt axles and early drums on the rear . 
But you may have a point on the adjusters , the slot is angled isn't it . I'll check this evening .


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: gkeeton@zbzoom.net on December 17, 2016, 04:48:10 am
Definitely double check the compatibility, and orientation of the adjusters. Even if you have the correct angled adjuster, make sure the angle is correct. Do you have new drums? If not, the new shoes may only be touching in the middle of the shoe, and actually bending the drum out of round with a small pressure point instead of the full shoe.


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 18, 2016, 11:11:42 am
Definitely double check the compatibility, and orientation of the adjusters. Even if you have the correct angled adjuster, make sure the angle is correct. Do you have new drums? If not, the new shoes may only be touching in the middle of the shoe, and actually bending the drum out of round with a small pressure point instead of the full shoe.

I just checked the adjusters , and they are correct , and the correct way around . the drums and shoes are new .
I just now , removed a shoe and offered up to the drum . they certainkey tounch in the middle first , but the gap under each end of the shoe is less than half mm .  is that bad ? Obviously they'll need some bedding in , but that wouldn't cause the problems I'm having would it ?

Thanks , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 18, 2016, 11:45:01 am
Try it without line lock?


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 18, 2016, 12:23:38 pm
No I haven't , but when the line lock is open , its just a T piece , I can't see why it would make any difference to remove it .

I have checked everything I can think of mechanically , there just HAS to be air in there . I will try the suggestion to jack one end of the car up , and just keep bleeding .

Thanks , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: mr horsepower on December 18, 2016, 13:20:25 pm
hi rob
i had the exact problem once..
i went the same route as you
later it turned out to be the hoses and dustcovers on the wheel cilinders were balooning
but the didnt leak
good luck

gr henri


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: mr horsepower on December 18, 2016, 13:22:29 pm
forgot to say
these where new parts at that time..
thats why i beter use a used org part then a new knock off !!


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 18, 2016, 20:55:53 pm
hi rob
i had the exact problem once..
i went the same route as you
later it turned out to be the hoses and dustcovers on the wheel cilinders were balooning
but the didnt leak
good luck

gr henri

Thanks Henri , this sounds like it could be the problem .

Had a visit from Richie and Jo today and we isolated the problem to the front end . With the line lock ON , the pedal is hard .

Then with Jo squeezing one front hose with pliers and richie the other , pedal felt good . So its gotta be hoses / wheel cylinders .

Richie suggested wrong wheel cylinders , but I checked the part number , they are correct , but reproduction . I'm gonna order up some good quality hoses  ( any suggestions ?)  And wheel cylinders . Maybe shoes too .

Thanks for everyones input so far , and Richie and Jo's help today . I will report back once I've tried the new parts .

Cheers , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: modnrod on December 18, 2016, 21:32:28 pm
I'm gonna order up some good quality hoses  ( any suggestions ?)  And wheel cylinders . Maybe shoes too .


and......there is my opening to ask a question.
 ;D

I am also needing new hoses and rear cylinders and since this company looks after Orstrayuns like me VERY well with freight deals and despatch times, are the brand parts listed here also OK (different model to yours Rob)?
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/281611775B/brake-hose-front-t2-71-1302-3-340mm-ff/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/113611775E/brake-hose-rr-irs-1302-03-250mm-mf/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/361611067AATE/wheel-cylinder-ate-fr-1302-3-rr-t3-squareback-65-23-8mm/?crumbStartPage=3&crumbStartRow=95

I've had the same sort of dramas before that you are having Rob, I feel your pain.
 ;)


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 18, 2016, 23:04:25 pm
I'm gonna order up some good quality hoses  ( any suggestions ?)  And wheel cylinders . Maybe shoes too .


and......there is my opening to ask a question.
 ;D

I am also needing new hoses and rear cylinders and since this company looks after Orstrayuns like me VERY well with freight deals and despatch times, are the brand parts listed here also OK (different model to yours Rob)?
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/281611775B/brake-hose-front-t2-71-1302-3-340mm-ff/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/113611775E/brake-hose-rr-irs-1302-03-250mm-mf/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/361611067AATE/wheel-cylinder-ate-fr-1302-3-rr-t3-squareback-65-23-8mm/?crumbStartPage=3&crumbStartRow=95

I've had the same sort of dramas before that you are having Rob, I feel your pain.
 ;)


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 18, 2016, 23:08:12 pm
I'm gonna order up some good quality hoses  ( any suggestions ?)  And wheel cylinders . Maybe shoes too .


and......there is my opening to ask a question.
 ;D

I am also needing new hoses and rear cylinders and since this company looks after Orstrayuns like me VERY well with freight deals and despatch times, are the brand parts listed here also OK (different model to yours Rob)?
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/281611775B/brake-hose-front-t2-71-1302-3-340mm-ff/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/113611775E/brake-hose-rr-irs-1302-03-250mm-mf/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/361611067AATE/wheel-cylinder-ate-fr-1302-3-rr-t3-squareback-65-23-8mm/?crumbStartPage=3&crumbStartRow=95

I've had the same sort of dramas before that you are having Rob, I feel your pain.
 ;)

Thanks !   I only manage to get a few hours a week on the bug , so its painful spending so many of those precious hours pissing into the wind !

I'm tempted to get some Goodrich hoses , but I've never felt the need before , and have never had such big problems with standard replacement parts .

Cheers , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 20, 2016, 19:03:41 pm
Brakes Sorted !
I bought new , German hoses , cylinders and shoes .
New cylinders were at least 5 mm longer than the old ones , which accounts for the amount of adjustment I had to do .
Shies fitted the profile of the drum perfectly , and the liner on the new shoes was tons longer too !  Fitted it all up , bled in a few minutes , and all done


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 20, 2016, 19:05:04 pm
Thanks for everyone's advise and ideas , thank to Jo and Richie for their help , and my mate fast Eddie for pedal pumping

Cheers , Rob


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 20, 2016, 19:34:21 pm
Can you let us know what parts were fitted previously so we can all avoid them!
Glad you got it sorted
Lee


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Andrew on December 20, 2016, 20:30:50 pm
Excellent news, + 1 for Lee's suggestion.


Title: Re: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Jo Clifford on December 20, 2016, 21:08:30 pm
Thanks for everyone's advise and ideas , thank to Jo and Richie for their help , and my mate fast Eddie for pedal pumping

Cheers , Rob
Good news, glad we were able to help.    :D


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 20, 2016, 23:36:15 pm
I'll check the part number tomorrow to see if I can figure out what the crap ones were . the part number was , laser printed on , which made them look cheap .
New ones are Bendix .



Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 20, 2016, 23:40:54 pm
So it came out of the shed under its own steam ! Then went back in , as I don't have a fan belt ....or an oil cooler !


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: leec on December 20, 2016, 23:58:20 pm
Looks very nice  ;D


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: RobtheManx on December 21, 2016, 00:27:06 am
Thanks Lee ! Its filthy , but you can't tell in the pix .

The crappy wheel cylinders were made by JP group  , part number 816-1300-400-utter-crap


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: modnrod on December 21, 2016, 01:52:51 am

The crappy wheel cylinders were made by JP group ..........

*sigh*
Well, looks like I might still need new wheel cylinders after all then........

On a brighter note, car looks great man!
 8)


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: henk on December 22, 2016, 09:17:21 am
Nice callooker,love the color.

Henk!!!


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: DougB on December 22, 2016, 23:31:12 pm
I'm gonna order up some good quality hoses  ( any suggestions ?)  And wheel cylinders . Maybe shoes too .


and......there is my opening to ask a question.
 ;D

I am also needing new hoses and rear cylinders and since this company looks after Orstrayuns like me VERY well with freight deals and despatch times, are the brand parts listed here also OK (different model to yours Rob)?
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/281611775B/brake-hose-front-t2-71-1302-3-340mm-ff/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/113611775E/brake-hose-rr-irs-1302-03-250mm-mf/?crumbStartPage=2&crumbStartRow=55
https://au.vwheritage.com/shop/beetle/361611067AATE/wheel-cylinder-ate-fr-1302-3-rr-t3-squareback-65-23-8mm/?crumbStartPage=3&crumbStartRow=95

I've had the same sort of dramas before that you are having Rob, I feel your pain.
 ;)

Thanks !   I only manage to get a few hours a week on the bug , so its painful spending so many of those precious hours pissing into the wind !

I'm tempted to get some Goodrich hoses , but I've never felt the need before , and have never had such big problems with standard replacement parts .

Cheers , Rob

They are worth the extra £


Title: Re: Brake bleeding driving me nuts !
Post by: Jim Ratto on February 16, 2017, 23:30:01 pm
So it came out of the shed under its own steam ! Then went back in , as I don't have a fan belt ....or an oil cooler !

Nice looking car. Glad you got the brakes sorted out.