I helped a friend put one of those "low profile" shrouds on a type 3 not too long ago and we were prettty pleased with it. Also, with a little careful grinding, you can remove all of those litle tabs n the front of it.
are they worth the money?
I thought so. It wasn't much more than the aftermarket 36 horsepower doghouse type shrouds, plus it's a genuine VW part so the fit and overall quality of it was nice.