I agree - keep the original alloys!
I recently went thru what you're considering (not really in favor of the "sucked in" look either). I opted to try the newly released repops from EMPI. I have to say I'm pleased with over all finish - Only time will tell how they'll survive the (somewhat
) harsh climate offered here in Sweden
.
With the 42mm off set and 5" width I personally think they fit nicely under the front wings (2" narrowed beam) - A few pix @
www.acswede.blogspot.com which may give you an idea of the fit.