The Cal-look Lounge
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email?
November 01, 2024, 00:23:58 am
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Thank you for your support!
Search:
Advanced search
351145
Posts in
28649
Topics by
6850
Members
Latest Member:
Bugstar70_new
The Cal-look Lounge
Cal-look/High Performance
Cal-look
My Road Trip Motor Progress
« previous
next »
Pages:
1
...
3
4
[
5
]
6
7
8
Author
Topic: My Road Trip Motor Progress (Read 90299 times)
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #120 on:
August 23, 2012, 14:06:49 pm »
Hey JHU....nice blog you have running. The intent of this thread is to get people thinking. There is no "ONE WAY" to do everything. If that were the case, there would be one car manufacturer, one home builder, one plastics manufacturer, etc., etc., etc. . Innovation is the result of trying different ideas and still achieving results. Having driven dual carb motors on the street since 1970, I am always looking for new ways to improve my street motor and street-ability. There are a lot of different ways to achieve a desired result.
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
richie
Hero Member
Posts: 5687
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #121 on:
August 25, 2012, 22:12:47 pm »
Quote from: rick m on August 19, 2012, 01:14:48 am
Keep in mind you do not want a lot of deck. I run "0" deck with a copper gasket. I know Joel is running a tight deck too. .
Rick M
Rick I am just catching up having been away for 10 days,but something I want to point out that i am sure you know but is a little missleading
you are not running 0 deck,you are running 0.050 deck if your copper gasket is 0.050 and you set the piston at zero with the top of the cylinder,
some may not understand that from what you wrote,and tight deck is a relative term,for me 0.035-0.040 is "tight deck" but everyone has there own ideas on that
You will need 58-63cc in your heads with that 0.050 deck in a 2276 to get 9-9.5/1 compression which is still pretty large,are you thinking of using dished pistons as well in this engine?
I too am interested to see you final chamber shape after you have flycut it down,dont forget the camera before you assemble the engine
cheers richie
Logged
Cars are supposed to be driven, not just talked about!!!
Good parts might be expensive but good advice is priceless
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #122 on:
August 26, 2012, 03:07:41 am »
Richie,
I have 62cc in the head at this time. Still working on it. Not done with the final shape. I like those dished Weisco's you show on your website. :-)
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
Zach Gomulka
Hero Member
Posts: 6991
Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining.
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #123 on:
August 26, 2012, 14:14:04 pm »
Rick, how much have you flycut the heads so far? I imagine your heads pre flycut must have been in the 72cc-ish range? What was your deck height and compression previously?
Logged
Born in the '80s, stuck in the '70s.
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #124 on:
August 27, 2012, 16:14:18 pm »
Another shot of the chambers after polishing. Not quite finished yet. One final CC to determine if I at my target figure after I align the barrel seating area with the cylinders.
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
andy198712
Hero Member
Posts: 1063
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #125 on:
August 27, 2012, 18:39:14 pm »
nice! what tools are you using for this? ie what grits ect?
i'm still pondering my chamber design, i've just unshrouded to the barrel and blended it, removed any sharp edges where the seats were cut and its looking pretty open to me....
Logged
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #126 on:
August 27, 2012, 20:09:15 pm »
I use some carbide cutters for some of the blending, then move to 60 and 80 grit cylindrical sanding cones used on a 13,000 air powered die grinder (with 1/4" arbor for the cones). Will post some pictures tonight. I then go to a 180 grit cone to get the majority of all sanding marks reduced so my polishing compounds and buffing tools do the rest. The intent of smoothing the machined and cast portions of the chamber are to create a reflective affect where the head is not a heat sink. It is a less expensive way of doing this than having space age coatings applied. If you have the money, the thermal barriers are worth it. I am doing it this way to test it out. I have done both.
I still have a little more shaping and blending to ensure that the top of the piston as it slams toward the combustion chamber is not pushing against any steps or sharp corners. Will post shots when the final chamber and CC work is done. I also polish the tops of my pistons.
RM
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
Zach Gomulka
Hero Member
Posts: 6991
Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining.
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #127 on:
August 28, 2012, 04:51:41 am »
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemi_engine#section_2
Quote from: Zach Gomulka on August 26, 2012, 14:14:04 pm
Rick, how much have you flycut the heads so far? I imagine your heads pre flycut must have been in the 72cc-ish range? What was your deck height and compression previously?
Logged
Born in the '80s, stuck in the '70s.
karl h
Hero Member
Posts: 931
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #128 on:
August 28, 2012, 07:21:26 am »
limbach aircraft heads have something like a semi-hemi chamber
Logged
61 panel
http://www.thesamba.com/vw/forum/viewtopic.php?t=465022
68 ghia vert
63 sunroof
http://cal-look.no/lounge/index.php/topic,27456.0.html
86 caravelle
04 new beetle vert
andy198712
Hero Member
Posts: 1063
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #129 on:
August 28, 2012, 23:45:01 pm »
Quote from: rick m on August 27, 2012, 20:09:15 pm
I use some carbide cutters for some of the blending, then move to 60 and 80 grit cylindrical sanding cones used on a 13,000 air powered die grinder (with 1/4" arbor for the cones). Will post some pictures tonight. I then go to a 180 grit cone to get the majority of all sanding marks reduced so my polishing compounds and buffing tools do the rest. The intent of smoothing the machined and cast portions of the chamber are to create a reflective affect where the head is not a heat sink. It is a less expensive way of doing this than having space age coatings applied. If you have the money, the thermal barriers are worth it. I am doing it this way to test it out. I have done both.
I still have a little more shaping and blending to ensure that the top of the piston as it slams toward the combustion chamber is not pushing against any steps or sharp corners. Will post shots when the final chamber and CC work is done. I also polish the tops of my pistons.
RM
Thanks for going over that for me bud!
did you notice any benifit with either the coatings or polishing? how did they look when torn down?
Thanks
Logged
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #130 on:
August 29, 2012, 07:12:12 am »
Andy,
The intent with both is to reflect the heat into the combustion area and out the exhaust rather than have the head absorb it as a heat sink. However, being an aircooled head, obviously the head will dissipate heat through the surface areas of the fins and the fan will (if working correctly) blow it off the head. The open chamber design is not just for lower compression as some seem so stuck on thinking. Other improvements I know work and I am working to achieve is to reduce heat retention and have it help the combustion and torque produced.
Will show the results when the motor is back together. Again, I am not trying to be an 11 second street car. Just a car that can drive anywhere, any distance, in any weather, any time. Already did it with one combination during the early days of the BERG CRUISE to Detroit (1997). Working on a variation of that with this new motor.
RM
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
andy198712
Hero Member
Posts: 1063
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #131 on:
August 29, 2012, 09:51:52 am »
Quote from: rick m on August 29, 2012, 07:12:12 am
Andy,
The intent with both is to reflect the heat into the combustion area and out the exhaust rather than have the head absorb it as a heat sink. However, being an aircooled head, obviously the head will dissipate heat through the surface areas of the fins and the fan will (if working correctly) blow it off the head. The open chamber design is not just for lower compression as some seem so stuck on thinking. Other improvements I know work and I am working to achieve is to reduce heat retention and have it help the combustion and torque produced.
Will show the results when the motor is back together. Again, I am not trying to be an 11 second street car. Just a car that can drive anywhere, any distance, in any weather, any time. Already did it with one combination during the early days of the BERG CRUISE to Detroit (1997). Working on a variation of that with this new motor.
RM
Cheers bud, i agree on your points, and i guess the coatings help get more heat out to the exhaust instead of soaking into the head, longer life span, happier engine. i have similar goals to you, reliability close to a stock engine
Logged
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #132 on:
September 02, 2012, 22:56:48 pm »
Spent Saturday finishing up the final polishing on my combustion chambers. Will be running a .04635 copper gasket between the heads and the barrels (running "0" deck in the barrel). With my combustion chamber mods and cam grind, will be running a FLAT TOP (not dished piston) on this redo. Ended up with 65cc in the heads.
From here...the assembly begins. Running a 106 lobe center cam with .473 lift at the valve. Intake valve will close at 35 ABDC to achieve the dynamic compression we were looking to hit. Cam grind was ground to help me achieve my driveability goals of coming off idle to 5000-5500.
We are calculating for 7.6 dynamic compression and 8.7 to 8.8 for the static compression and running on 91 octane pump gas. Primary goals are driveability, improved bottom end and better cooling. Top end after 5500 is not a consideration for this combo as the cam design will simply not achieve any measurable increase in horsepower after 5500 to 6000 rpm.
Rick M
«
Last Edit: September 03, 2012, 06:22:15 am by rick m
»
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #133 on:
September 06, 2012, 06:37:06 am »
Finished the chambers on my street heads, polished the crowns of the pistons and dialed in the cam this weekend. Now it goes back together. Will be interesting to see what was accomplished towards gaining more torque down low.
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
13bussing
Newbie
Posts: 6
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #134 on:
September 09, 2012, 11:25:06 am »
I'm liking this polsing lark allot.
Am I right in thinking it would be so good in turboed engine?? Getting more heat in to the turbo should help with the turbo spool earlier.
Logged
jamiep_jamiep
Hero Member
Posts: 1587
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #135 on:
September 11, 2012, 10:19:47 am »
How soon would you expect any build up of the waste products of combustion on the finish Rick, and how would that diminish the effect? Do they need to be redone every so often or something?
Logged
Happiness is a Hot VW.
My 1960 Bug
SAS RENN-WAGENS
CAL LOOK DRAG DAY
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #136 on:
September 12, 2012, 16:30:43 pm »
The heads will carbon up relatively soon. Polishing helps tighten the material (get rid of porosity). It is not nearly as good as a ceramic coating but a poor mans way to make incremental improvements. My main objective was really the shape of the combustion chamber for quench. I am running a .0465 copper gasket on top my cylinders with "0" deck in the bore. Just finishing final assembly of the motor this week. Completed cam degree exercise and checked all clearances last week. My cam has 2 degrees advance built into the cam. Running 478 lift and 218 duration at .050 with 106 lobe centers.
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
Zach Gomulka
Hero Member
Posts: 6991
Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining.
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #137 on:
September 13, 2012, 02:23:52 am »
"
Top
of the page" cam, Rick?
Logged
Born in the '80s, stuck in the '70s.
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #138 on:
September 13, 2012, 02:31:47 am »
Top of the page...NO. Had the cam ground for what I am trying to accomplish rather than taking one off of any page or out of any catalog.
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
Taylor
Hero Member
Posts: 577
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #139 on:
September 13, 2012, 05:38:25 am »
218*@.050 is a typing error, right? With that little duration, I don't care how much overlap you machine the cam with, at 8.8to1 I would think it would detonate.
Logged
Zach Gomulka
Hero Member
Posts: 6991
Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining.
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #140 on:
September 13, 2012, 14:13:47 pm »
It was a joke, Rick. A joke.
Logged
Born in the '80s, stuck in the '70s.
rick m
Hero Member
Posts: 1296
Driving Hot VWs for 44 Years Strong!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #141 on:
September 13, 2012, 15:36:02 pm »
Zach....not my first rodeo. I get it. :-)
Rick M
Logged
Rick Mortensen
Driving Hot VWs since 1970
Fasterbrit
Hero Member
Posts: 1009
OFF#23 - The Fastest Outlaw in the West!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #142 on:
September 13, 2012, 16:54:03 pm »
Keep up the good work Rick
Logged
9.563 @ 146.25 mph Cal Look Drag Day, Santa Pod, April 2011
OFF#23 OUTLAW FLAT FOUR
www.outlawflatfour.com
www.air-kraft.com
www.marcomansiperformance.com
John Maher
Full Member
Posts: 140
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #143 on:
September 14, 2012, 11:00:26 am »
An interesting read.
I first started using the Berg semi-hemi cut in the late '80s. I've never regarded it as a performance enhancing mod, more a quick and easy way to lower compression ratio by increasing combustion chamber volume. Before that, the only way to increase chamber volume was to reshape the chambers by hand - a laborious task, especially if you're looking for an increase of 4cc per chamber or more - involving hours of die grinding cc-ing, more grinding etc etc. In the '80s and'90s I was building street motors with much lower CR than I use nowadays, plus the fact most heads suitable for street use back then had smaller chamber volumes than the heads we have nowadays (eg 044s). Short of running a ton of deck height (strictly verboten) or dishing the piston, finding more volume in the chamber was the way to go to arrive at the target CR.
One of the clues as to why the semi-hemi cut combustion chamber doesn't perform on a par with a well designed wedge type chamber can be found in the instructions Berg provides with the semi-hemi tool: he mentions having to run more ignition advance to achieve best performance. As a general rule you'll find less efficient chamber designs require more advance i.e. it takes longer to burn all the air fuel mixture so you have to start the fire earlier. Looking at a modern engine design, a typical four valve per cylinder layout with centrally located spark plug will run a max advance of around 20° BTDC. If you can achieve best results with less ignition timing, you have less pumping losses and therefore more power delivered to the flywheel.
On most of the street engines I build nowadays there's no need to go in search of extra chamber volume - partly because I run higher CR than I used to but also because the majority of aftermarket heads start out with larger chambers than I had to work with 20+ years ago. A few weeks ago I dug out the semi-hemi cutter for the first time in years. The project was a mild 2110cc bus motor, with stock heads, Engle 110 and a pair of 40IDFs. I start with a fixed deck of .045" and then calculated the required chamber volume. The semi-hemi route was the quickest and easiest way to get where I needed. On the dyno I started with an initial max advance of 32°. Increasing timing by a couple of degrees at a time to find best performance. I finally settled on 38°. If I left it down around 30-32° I was giving up power and torque, plus the exhaust gas temps were running higher. I was perfectly happy with the end result and don't see any problem running semi-hemi heads on an engine of this type but for a higher performance orientated motor I'd always recommend a compact wedge chamber with large squish area and run a tight deck.
rick m... you mentioned you were reducing surface area by using the semi-hemi chamber and further reducing it by blending in the sharp edges. If I understand you correctly, in fact you're doing the opposite and actually increasing surface area. By converting all (or most) of the flat squish/quench area into a concave form you have more surface area than you started with. Now more of the heat energy from combustion is absorbed by the head instead of acting on the piston.
On the subject of hemi cutting and then flycutting the head to get rid of some of the extra volume you've created....
A dyno test I carried out many years ago threw up something odd. I'd previously built a normally aspirated 2165cc race engine for a customer. He raced for a season, then brought the engine back for a refresh. He'd also acquired a pair of Super Flow heads from another racer that had been intended for a turbocharged engine. They'd been semi-hemi cut, with all the edges carefully hand-blended in. A really nice pair of heads but the chamber volume was HUGE! I can't recall the exact figures but CR would have been down in the 8s on the 2165cc n/a engine. I flycut them as much as I dare in order to increase CR. On the dyno all was fine until it got up around 6500rpm. At that point the engine started making this horrendous noise. It sounded like a box of firecrackers going off. Pushing it beyond 6500rpm towards 7000rpm and above the noise would go away. At the time I didn't figure out exactly what it was but subsequently came to the conclusion there was something weird going on in the combustion chamber as a result of the reduced height semi-hemi cut i.e. combustion efficiency was going haywire.
I fully accept semi-hemi heads can work just fine on a relatively mild torquey street engine - I've done it several times. But if you're building an engine where optimum performance and efficiency is the goal, I don't believe the semi-hemi approach, at least as I understand it, is the way to go.
Rick and Joel, hope you don't think I'm dissing your findings. If you're achieving good results in the real world with your updated version of the semi-hemi I can't argue against them and appreciate you sharing them on here. Just thought I'd chip in with a little of what I've experienced. Look forward to reading more of your reports.
All the best
JM
Logged
John Maher
Fasterbrit
Hero Member
Posts: 1009
OFF#23 - The Fastest Outlaw in the West!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #144 on:
September 14, 2012, 12:31:18 pm »
Just to add to the use of the semi-hemi chamber design in racing, the Salzburg Rally cars (Austrian Privateers) used the semi-hemi chamber with great results. It worked really well on the highly-tuned 1600's with twin Weber 46 IDAs. Reading the info on the cars, the team found it worked for their given application. Unfortunately, they don't go into great detail as to why it worked much better, perhaps it has something to do with the duration of the events and how long the car would be subject to full-throttle and heavy loading. It would be really interesting to find out their specific CR...
«
Last Edit: September 14, 2012, 12:33:49 pm by All Torque
»
Logged
9.563 @ 146.25 mph Cal Look Drag Day, Santa Pod, April 2011
OFF#23 OUTLAW FLAT FOUR
www.outlawflatfour.com
www.air-kraft.com
www.marcomansiperformance.com
Jon
Administrator
Hero Member
Posts: 3214
12,3@174km/t at Gardermoen 2008
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #145 on:
September 14, 2012, 12:41:10 pm »
http://www.1302super.com/page35.html
Logged
Grumpy old men have signatures like this.
Fasterbrit
Hero Member
Posts: 1009
OFF#23 - The Fastest Outlaw in the West!
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #146 on:
September 14, 2012, 12:47:45 pm »
Thanks JHU! 9.1 CR and 120 hp for a 1600 is pretty darn respectable! And all through 39mm intakes and 32mm exhaust valves...
They were very reliable cars, too
Logged
9.563 @ 146.25 mph Cal Look Drag Day, Santa Pod, April 2011
OFF#23 OUTLAW FLAT FOUR
www.outlawflatfour.com
www.air-kraft.com
www.marcomansiperformance.com
Jon
Administrator
Hero Member
Posts: 3214
12,3@174km/t at Gardermoen 2008
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #147 on:
September 14, 2012, 13:33:09 pm »
Logged
Grumpy old men have signatures like this.
John Maher
Full Member
Posts: 140
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #148 on:
September 14, 2012, 13:40:15 pm »
Quote from: All Torque on September 14, 2012, 12:47:45 pm
Thanks JHU! 9.1 CR and 120 hp for a 1600 is pretty darn respectable! And all through 39mm intakes and 32mm exhaust valves...
They were very reliable cars, too
More than respectable, especially considering it was back in the early '70s!
A quick bit of maths.... assuming a deck height of 1mm, it takes a chamber volume of 43cc to arrive at 9.1 CR (flat top piston).
They'd've had to heavily flycut an 040 hemi chamber to achieve that, which brings us back to Rick and Joel's method and therefore contradicts what I said above!
There are more than a few engine builders today who could extract superior performance from the same configuration - but that's only to be expected with the benefit of 40+ years progress
Logged
John Maher
Jon
Administrator
Hero Member
Posts: 3214
12,3@174km/t at Gardermoen 2008
Re: Open Chamber Head Mods for my Road Trip Motor
«
Reply #149 on:
September 14, 2012, 14:01:03 pm »
Quote from: John Maher on September 14, 2012, 13:40:15 pm
Quote from: All Torque on September 14, 2012, 12:47:45 pm
Thanks JHU! 9.1 CR and 120 hp for a 1600 is pretty darn respectable! And all through 39mm intakes and 32mm exhaust valves...
They were very reliable cars, too
More than respectable, especially considering it was back in the early '70s!
A quick bit of maths.... assuming a deck height of 1mm, it takes a chamber volume of 43cc to arrive at 9.1 CR (flat top piston).
They'd've had to heavily flycut an 040 hemi chamber to achieve that, which brings us back to Rick and Joel's method and therefore contradicts what I said above!
There are more than a few engine builders today who could extract superior performance from the same configuration - but that's only to be expected with the benefit of 40+ years progress
Thanks for contributing John! Are you up for a bit of guessing? What would be a possible gain of removing the squish area like the salzburg boys have done. And would the engine run cooler with squish?
Logged
Grumpy old men have signatures like this.
Pages:
1
...
3
4
[
5
]
6
7
8
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Cal-look/High Performance
-----------------------------
=> Cal-look
=> Pure racing
=> Technical stuff
=> Top Racers lists
=> In Da Werks
-----------------------------
The Cal-look classifieds
-----------------------------
=> For sale!
=> Wanted
-----------------------------
Happenings
-----------------------------
=> Happenings
=> Scandinavian Cal-look Classic (the event)
-----------------------------
Tyre kicking
-----------------------------
=> Off Topic
Loading...